If I had the internet speeds, I'd be glad to download all the roms, try them out and post a review on YT. Unfortunately, my speeds are really, really terrible. Unfortunately, due to some bad life situations, I no longer have high speed and have to resort to tethering my netbook to my pay-by-month phone. They cap me pretty quick and the result is like taking a trip back about 20 years. It's awful.
So I wish someone would post something like that. Run some benchmarks. Show some footage from games between different roms so we can see how different roms handle different games. List pros and cons. Etc.
For me, I not only have very limited internet but HD space as well, since I no longer have my desktop. So I'd want a backup or the original ROM file for my current config. For me to upgrade, it would take a lot of time and work, so I like to read a lot of experiences before taking the plunge on a ROM.
Good thread and I hope we can get some critiques, comparisons and good opinions.